About ACNM
News & Events
Continuing Education & Practice Resources
Become a Midwife
Member Services
Corporate Opportunities
Legislation & Health Policy
Publications & Research
Global Programs
Support Midwifery
Shop ACNM
Consumer Information
Journal of Midwifery & Women's Health



For Immediate Release -- March 21, 2006
Contact: Tim Clarke, Jr.
office: (240) 485-1821
cell: (301) 814-2678

Download a PDF version

ACNM: "Unnecessary cesarean sections threaten
the future health of mother and child"

Silver Spring, MD - The following are remarks presented by Katherine Camacho Carr, CNM, PhD, FACNM, president of the American College of Nurse-Midwives (ACNM), at a media briefing on March 20th in Washington, D.C.  The briefing, part of the ongoing ACNM REDUCE Campaign, featured a presentation of the only systematic review of the literature on cesarean delivery, as well as the release of new research data about the experiences and views of women related to cesareans.  The media briefing was held just one week before the start of an NIH 'state-of-the-science' conference titled 'Cesarean Delivery on Maternal Request.'  More information about the ACNM REDUCE Campaign, including resources from the briefing, can be found online at www.midwife.org

The REDUCE Campaign stands for 'research and education to decrease unnecessary cesarean sections,' and is a public service campaign from the American College of Nurse-Midwives and its partners. 

Remarks by Katherine Camacho Carr, CNM, PhD, president of the American College of Nurse-Midwives:

"Good morning and thank you for coming.

Unnecessary cesarean sections threaten the future health of mother and child, and are being performed on more and more women without a clear understanding of the risks of this major surgical procedure.  As specialists in women's health care, midwives are very concerned that decisions to perform surgery are being made based on circumstantial evidence, misinterpretation of evidence and/or on lack of respect for the short and long term risks of this major abdominal surgery. 

In just one week from today, the National Institutes of Health will convene a State of the Science Conference on Cesarean Delivery on Maternal Request.  During that two-and-a-half day event, we can expect to learn more about what the scientific literature says about the risks and benefits of what we believe should be the most infrequent surgical procedure known to women.  Maternal request for cesarean delivery is a surgical indication that is not clearly defined and is probably a result of inadequate information or misrepresentation of the options available, and in some cases, is the result from coercion based on the preferences of the providers and institutions that find spontaneous vaginal delivery a major inconvenience. 

The College and our partners are also extremely concerned that a major element of the cesarean debate - the voices of women experiencing complications from cesarean section - have and will continue to be unheard.  It is for that reason we are gathered here today. 

Let me be clear that we believe that the vast majority of physicians and hospitals are doing the right thing when it comes to maternal request for cesarean section.  Many physicians share our concern that what should be an extremely rare event may become a cultural norm, because it fits into a health system that puts cost savings and convenience above good medical judgment.  It fits into a health care system that does not value prevention and education bur routinely applies technologies that are life-saving for some, but not without complications for others.

Specifically, the motivations may be financial: hospitals can maximize revenue per procedure and perform more procedures each day.  They may be physical: hospitals can exert more control over staffing schedules and workforce needs.  Some hospitals and physicians tell us they are responding to peer pressure as they do not want to lose patients to their competitors.  Finally, there is the fear of litigation-physicians often refer to fear of lawsuits as a motivation for performing a cesarean, even when they do not believe it is necessary. 

This country has a major problem that must be resolved before women can be told the truth about the risks of cesarean section.  There is no national databank that links subsequent complications such as those you will hear described today to the original surgical procedure.  Thus, any conclusions about the risks of cesarean section are mere speculation, and some of those conclusions are potentially life-threatening.

Women must be told the truth about the long and short tem risks of surgical birth.  They only get to make the decision once as scars and adhesions last forever.  A uterus lost to complications of cesarean section cannot be replaced. 

The REDUCE Campaign's purpose is to give voice to the women who have suffered long-term problems resulting from a cesarean birth.  We know there are women who are disabled, who have lost their ability to bear a child, who are permanently scarred because of their cesarean birth.  

When you hear their stories, you too will want to go back to the days when we did not take the decision to do a cesarean section lightly.  As clinicians, we believe that if a woman is harmed or dies from complications related to a cesarean birth, we want her and her family to know that the surgery was necessary. 

I want to take a moment to acknowledge the generous support from our REDUCE Campaign partners - the American Association of Birth Centers, Citizens for Midwifery, the Coalition for Improving Maternity Services, International Cesarean Awareness Network, and Lamaze International."

For more information about the ACNM REDUCE Campaign, please visit www.midwife.org.

###

With roots dating to 1929, the American College of Nurse-Midwives is the oldest women's health care association in the U.S.  ACNM's mission is to promote the health and well-being of women and newborns within their families and communities through the development and support of the profession of midwifery as practiced by certified nurse-midwives and certified midwives.  Midwives believe every individual has the right to safe, satisfying health care with respect for human dignity and cultural variations.  More information about ACNM can be found at www.midwife.org.

For more information, please contact Tim Clarke, Jr., ACNM Associate Director, Communications, at 240-485-1821 or via e-mail.

   
About ACNM News & Events Continuing Education & Practice Resources Become a Midwife
Member Services Legislation & Health Policy Publications & Research Global Programs
Support Midwifery Shop ACNM Consumer Information Journal of Midwifery & Women's Health
Find a Midwife Midwifejobs.com Search Site Contact Us Home

© 2005 American College of Nurse-Midwives. All Rights Reserved. Legal Notices
8403 Colesville Rd, Suite 1550 Silver Spring MD 20910
Phone: 240-485-1800 Fax: 240-485-1818 Web: www.midwife.org